NYPD’s Jessica Tisch Fires Back After Snowball Case Fallout — As Mayor Mamdani Downplays Incident, DA Bragg Drops Assault Charge
NYPD’s Jessica Tisch Fires Back After Snowball Case Fallout — As Mayor Mamdani Downplays Incident, DA Bragg Drops Assault Charge
By City Hall Bureau
NEW YORK — NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch issued a forceful defense of rank-and-file officers after Manhattan prosecutors dropped an assault charge tied to a snowball-pelting incident — and as Mayor Zohran Mamdani appeared to downplay the episode.
The controversy erupted after video circulated showing individuals throwing packed snowballs at responding officers during a winter disturbance. The Manhattan District Attorney’s Office, led by Alvin Bragg, later dismissed the misdemeanor assault count, citing evidentiary standards.
NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch insists cops “deserve to be treated with respect.”
❄️ “Not a Joke,” Tisch Says
In remarks to reporters, Tisch defended the officers involved, arguing that assaults on police — even if framed as pranks — can escalate quickly and pose safety risks.
“Throwing objects at officers performing their duties is not harmless,” she said. “Our members deserve respect and protection under the law.”
Police officials have noted that packed snowballs can contain ice or debris and, in some cases, cause injury.
🏛️ Political Crosscurrents
Mayor Mamdani, responding to questions about the case, suggested the situation did not warrant heavy-handed prosecution — a stance that has drawn criticism from police advocates who say it undermines officer safety.
The DA’s office has emphasized that assault charges require proof of physical injury or intent, and that each case is evaluated based on available evidence.
District Attorney Alvin Bragg downgraded the charges against the punks who tossed icy snowballs at officers.FNTV
⚖️ Legal Threshold
Under New York law, third-degree assault generally requires demonstrable physical injury. Legal analysts say prosecutors must assess whether the facts meet statutory requirements beyond a reasonable doubt.
Some critics argue the dismissal reflects broader tensions between city leaders and law enforcement. Others contend it shows appropriate restraint in minor altercations.
🚨 Bigger Debate
The episode has reignited debate over how New York balances public disorder, prosecutorial discretion and police morale.
For now, the assault charge is off the table — but the political fallout is far from over.
The suspect, Gusmane Coulibaly of the Bronx, was charged with assault on an officer, obstruction of governmental administration and disorderly conduct.
